The Danger of Conflation

What is Antisemitism?

Since Hamas’s atrocious attack on October 7 and Israel’s near-immediate retaliatory bombings that have killed more than 18,000 Palestinians, Europe has seen a troubling surge in both state and private efforts to restrict criticism of Israel or support of “the Palestinian cause” with the stated goal of protecting against anti-Semitism. But how is anti-Semitism being defined, why so, and with what results?

In announcing their measures, most European states refer to a controversial definition of anti-Semitism endorsed by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) in 2016. This definition largely focuses on examples that include criticisms of Israel, leaving it open to manipulation for political aims. More recently, in 2021, a group of scholars from Holocaust, anti-Semitism, and genocide studies published the Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism (JDA), offering more specific guidelines for identifying anti-Semitism, particularly with regard to criticism and debate around the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and Zionism. Notably, the IHRA’s statement since October 7 focused rather on addressing anti-Semitism “regrettably homegrown in all our societies” and the danger of “blaming Jews for Israel’s actions.”

With these definitions in mind, how can we address the very real rise of anti-Semitism and Islamophobia in Europe against the backdrop of the Israel-Hamas war? How can we avoid entrenched positions that frame the Israel-Hamas war as a war between Jews and Palestinians? This panel discusses the dangers of discursively conflating Jews with the state of Israel and Palestinians (and pro-Palestinian voices) with Hamas and considers how to more productively define, recognize, and protect against anti-Semitism (acts or speech against “Jews as Jews”) and Islamophobia in the current climate.

About the speakers

Jessica Feldman is an Assistant Professor / Enseignante-Chercheuse in Communication, Media, and Culture at the American University of Paris and a fellow at the Netherlands Institute for Advanced Study (NIAS). She researches the political ramifications and potentials of emerging digital technologies (AI, digital security); specifically their capacity to facilitate or repress solidarity and collective self-governance.

Ayşenur Korkmaz is a research fellow at the Netherlands Institute for Advanced Study (NIAS) in Amsterdam. She earned her Ph.D. from the University of Amsterdam, at the department of  European Studies. Her current work focuses on the multifaceted aftereffects of the Armenian genocide in Soviet and post-Soviet Armenia. She explores how the genocide survivors and their descendants in Armenia have been reflecting on the violent past, losses, and expulsion from the ancestral homeland.

Jan Willem Duyvendak (moderator) is Distinguished Research Professor of Sociology at the University of Amsterdam and Director of NIAS-KNAW. His main fields of research currently are the transformation of the welfare state, belonging and “feeling at home,” and nativism. His latest books include Thuis. Het drama van een sentimentele samenleving (Amsterdam University Press 2017), Macht der gewoonte. Populisme in de polder (Walburg Pers 2022, with Menno Hurenkamp) and The Return of the Native. Can Liberalism Safeguard Us Against Nativism? (Oxford University Press 2022, with Josip Kešić).

Gerelateerde programma’s
02 02 24
Unboxing Gaza: Disrupted Histories and Photo Kegham

Kegham Djeghalian Sr founded the first photography studio of Gaza. Focusing on the legacy of this exceptional photographer, Özge Calafato and Karène Sanchez Summerer will be in discussion with his grandson, Kegham Djeghalian Jr, who works on activating the surviving fraction of his grandfather’s endangered archive. The talk will address the significance of preserving Gaza’s precarious visual history and cultural heritage in the light of the current critical crisis of Gaza.

Vrijdag 2 feb 2024 20:00 uur
12 04 24
Omvolking. Een gewelddadige complottheorie onder de loep

Omvolking. De term heeft zich vanuit extreemrechtse hoek een weg gebaand naar de mainstream politieke arena. Wat houdt omvolkingsdenken precies in, waar komt het vandaan en waarom is het een gevaarlijke ideologie? Ter gelegenheid van het boek The Politics of Replacement komen redacteur en auteurs deze middag samen om deze complottheorie ter discussie te stellen.

Vrijdag 12 apr 2024 17:00 uur
24 11 23
Debating Muslim Marriage

Unconventional Muslim marriages have been topics of heated public debate around the globe. Religious scholars, policy makers, political actors, media personalities, and women’s activists discuss, promote, or reject unregistered, transnational, interreligious and other boundary-crossing marriages. Couples entering into such marriages, however, have different concerns from those publicly discussed. At this event, we will present chapters from a newly published book that examines these debated marriages: Muslim Marriage and Non-Marriage. Where Religion and Politics Meet Intimate Lives, edited by Julie McBrien and Annelies Moors.

Vrijdag 24 nov 2023 17:00 uur